Challenging rent increases: When and how to use the tribunal process
Under the Renters' Rights Act, tenants have the right to request an independent tribunal to review proposed rent increases.
This process ensures that rents align with local market conditions and are not set arbitrarily by landlords.
When the tribunal route may be relevant
The tribunal process is designed for situations where proposed rent increases seem significantly higher than what comparable properties in the local market are charging.
A good starting point is to research what similar properties in your area are currently letting for. Consider:
Property size and number of bedrooms
Condition and age of the property
Location and local amenities
Whether bills or other services are included
If the proposed increase significantly exceeds typical rates for similar properties, the tribunal process may be an option worth exploring.
How First-tier Tribunals work
First-tier Tribunals are independent bodies that assess market rent, based on evidence from both landlords and tenants. Importantly, tribunals focus on the market rent of comparable properties rather than the affordability of the increase to the tenant. They aim to ensure rents reflect the local market, not personal financial circumstances.
The tribunal may:
Reduce the proposed increase
Maintain the current rent
In some cases, set a rent below the current rate if the evidence shows that the existing rent exceeds market norms
The evidence that matters
Strong cases typically rely on solid, objective market data. This includes:
Rental listings for comparable properties in the area
Recent letting agreements for similar homes
Clear documentation of the property’s actual condition
Evidence showing how your property compares to higher-priced homes in the area
The evidence should focus on market comparisons, not personal opinions or circumstances.
Understanding the process
Applications must be submitted within a specific timeframe after receiving a Section 13 rent increase notice. If this deadline is missed, the proposed increase will be enforceable, regardless of market conditions.
The application requires details such as current and proposed rent amounts, property specifics, and reasons why the increase seems excessive. Be sure to attach supporting evidence with your application.
Most tribunal decisions are made based on submitted documents without a formal hearing. However, tribunals may request property inspections or additional information from either party.
What landlords can present
Landlords are notified of the application and can submit evidence to justify the rent increase. This could include evidence of comparable properties supporting the higher rent or documentation of improvements made to the property.
It’s helpful to understand that landlords will also present evidence, so preparing a thorough and well-documented application is important.
Timing and outcomes
Tribunal decisions can take several weeks to issue. If the tribunal sets a lower rent than the one proposed, this becomes effective from the date specified in the Section 13 notice.
Any overpayment during the tribunal process would be refunded. The determined rent usually stays in effect for at least twelve months before another increase can be proposed.
Important considerations
Application fees apply, though remission schemes are available for those who meet certain financial criteria.
The process requires time and effort to gather evidence and complete the application.
Tribunals can only assess market rents based on the evidence provided.
There’s no guarantee of a favourable outcome.
The relationship factor
Challenging a rent increase through formal processes can affect the landlord-tenant relationship. While legal protections exist against retaliatory actions, the practical dynamics of the relationship may shift.
This doesn’t mean you shouldn’t exercise your rights, but it’s important to consider both the immediate and longer-term effects on the relationship.
Available support
Organisations such as Citizens Advice, Shelter, and local housing charities offer free guidance on the tribunal process and evidence preparation. These groups can help assess whether a challenge is warranted, based on local market conditions.
A balanced approach
The tribunal process is a valuable tool for ensuring that rent increases are in line with market realities. However, it works best when based on clear evidence of genuine market discrepancies, rather than being used as a reaction to any rent increase.
Taking the time to thoroughly research local rents and understand the tribunal process can help inform whether challenging a rent increase is a reasonable and proportionate response.
If you’re unsure whether to challenge a rent increase, seeking independent housing advice can help clarify your options.
Seek independent housing advice to explore your options
This article was originally published by BriefYourMarket and is reproduced here with their permission.
For more company news and insights from Pygott & Crone, click here
Latest news
Bank holiday market activity: How it differs from standard weekends
Bank holiday weekends bring a noticeable shift in property market dynamics.
Challenging rent increases: When and how to use the tribunal process
Under the Renters' Rights Act, tenants have the right to request an independent tribunal to review proposed rent increases.
Competing in a spring market: Offer strategies when demand increases
Spring typically brings the busiest property market activity of the year.
Council tax bands explained: are you paying more than you should?
Council tax is one of the most overlooked household costs, yet the difference between bands can amount to hundreds, even thousands, of pounds over time.
